What Are Some Real-World Examples of Effective Key Risk Indicators (KRIs) in Action? (Part III)

As the Information Security Forum (ISF) continues to research security and risk management, one key observation stands out: many Chief Information Security Officers (CISOs) are reporting the wrong Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) and Key Risk Indicators (KRIs). If you're unsure about what metrics truly matter in risk management, you're not alone. This series has already tackled the fundamentals of KPIs and KRIs (Part I) and offered guidance on how to write effective KRIs (Part II). Now, in Part III, we bring it all together with real-world examples to help you craft and apply effective KRIs.

Why KRIs Matter:

KRIs act as an organization’s early-warning system, alerting management when risks exceed tolerable limits. While KPIs reflect past performance (like tracking breaches or system failures), KRIs help us foresee potential threats and allow for proactive measures. Think of them as the “crystal ball” of risk management—designed to predict and prevent damage before it happens.

Let’s dive into a few effective KRIs across different domains to give you some concrete ideas for what these indicators look like in practice.

Privacy KRIs: Protecting Sensitive Data

KRI: Percentage of third parties with access control issues identified as a critical risk

• Domain: Vendor Risk Management
• Risk: Unauthorized access by third parties due to access misuse.
• Why It Matters: Third-party risks can result in data breaches, compromising sensitive information. A KRI here helps track which vendors pose the most risk to your data security.

KRI: Percentage increase in policy exceptions from last year

• Domain: Privacy Policies
• Risk: Non-compliance with privacy policies, leading to exceptions that might expose the organization to legal issues.
• Why It Matters: An uptick in policy exceptions signals potential gaps in governance, which could lead to costly regulatory violations.

KRI: Percentage of high-risk issues newly identified during privacy impact assessments

• Domain: Privacy by Design
• Risk: Loss of confidential information, legal repercussions, and failure to comply with regulations like GDPR or CCPA.
• Why It Matters: Unaddressed privacy risks are a ticking time bomb for legal challenges and reputational damage.

Operational KRIs: Ensuring Business Continuity

KRI: Percentage of time system availability compared to scheduled availability

• Domain: Systems Management
• Risk: Unavailable systems can halt business operations, causing service failures and missed opportunities.
• Why It Matters: A drop in system availability could signal operational weaknesses that need addressing immediately.

KRI: Average time elapsed between system failures

• Domain: Systems Management
• Risk: Repeated or extended downtime can harm your company’s reputation, disrupt customer service, and lead to legal action.
• Why It Matters: Identifying this metric helps pinpoint areas where business continuity planning may be falling short.

KRI: Percentage of critical systems without up-to-date patches

• Domain: Systems Management
• Risk: Vulnerabilities from unpatched systems that could be exploited by attackers.
• Why It Matters: Without timely patches, organizations are exposed to cybersecurity threats, potentially costing time and money.

Logging or Lagging Indicators: Catching Problems Before They Escalate

KRI: Failed login attempts leading to increased password reset requests

• Domain: Access Control
• Risk: Inadequate access controls could lead to unauthorized access, data breaches, and loss of sensitive information.
• Why It Matters: A rise in failed logins and password resets is a red flag for potential attacks or weaknesses in user authentication.

KRI: Anomalies in privileged user account activity

• Domain: Access Control
• Risk: Misuse of privileged access could lead to data breaches or internal sabotage.
• Why It Matters: Monitoring privileged accounts closely helps detect potential insider threats before they cause significant damage.

KRI: An unusual volume of requests for a specific data file or access to certain servers

• Domain: Access Control
• Risk: This could signal a targeted attack or unauthorized attempt to access sensitive data.
• Why It Matters: Identifying abnormal behavior in real-time can help prevent data theft or system compromise.

Leading Indicators: Proactive Risk Management

KRI: Increase in social engineering and phishing attacks

• Domain: Information Security
• Risk: Lack of employee training leaves the organization vulnerable to attacks, resulting in data theft or financial loss.
• Why It Matters: Tracking phishing attempts allows you to take proactive measures, like training employees and reinforcing defenses against such attacks.

KRI: Percentage of satisfied customers to total customers

• Domain: Service Management
• Risk: Declining customer satisfaction can lead to churn, reduced revenue, and overall business failure.
• Why It Matters: Customer satisfaction is a leading indicator of business health, and monitoring this KRI helps ensure you're meeting market needs.

Leave a comment